The Case of the Speluncean Explorers involves five cave explorers trapped underground after a landslide seals the only known exit. After radio contact is established, rescuers and doctors tell the explorers that it will take about ten more days to reach them, and that they are unlikely to survive for that duration without food. The explorers ask whether they would survive if they consumed one member of the group, and the doctors indicated that they probably would. One of the explorers (Whetmore) proposes and the rest collectively agree to draw lots to decide who should be killed, but before the plan is carried out, Whetmore tries to withdraw from the arrangement. The others proceed anyway, draw the lot on his behalf, and he is selected. They kill Whetmore and eat him. The remaining explorers resultantly survive for the next ten days to be eventually rescued. After rescue, survivors are charged with murder under a law that provides that whoever wilfully takes the life of another shall be punished by death